Sportstime/SportsTimeTests/Planning/TripPlanningEngineTests.swift

//
//  TripPlanningEngineTests.swift
//  SportsTimeTests
//
//  Phase 7: TripPlanningEngine Integration Tests
//  Main orchestrator — tests all scenarios together.
//

import Testing
import CoreLocation
@testable import SportsTime

@Suite("TripPlanningEngine Tests", .serialized)
struct TripPlanningEngineTests {

    // MARK: - Test Fixtures

    private let calendar = Calendar.current

    /// Creates a fresh engine for each test to avoid parallel execution issues
    private func makeEngine() -> TripPlanningEngine {
        TripPlanningEngine()
    }

    /// Creates a date with specific year/month/day/hour
    private func makeDate(year: Int = 2026, month: Int = 6, day: Int, hour: Int = 19) -> Date {
        var components = DateComponents()
        components.year = year
        components.month = month
        components.day = day
        components.hour = hour
        components.minute = 0
        return calendar.date(from: components)!
    }

    /// Creates a stadium at a known location
    private func makeStadium(
        id: String = "stadium_test_\(UUID().uuidString)",
        city: String,
        lat: Double,
        lon: Double,
        sport: Sport = .mlb
    ) -> Stadium {
        Stadium(
            id: id,
            name: "\(city) Stadium",
            city: city,
            state: "ST",
            latitude: lat,
            longitude: lon,
            capacity: 40000,
            sport: sport
        )
    }

    /// Creates a game at a stadium
    private func makeGame(
        id: String = "game_test_\(UUID().uuidString)",
        stadiumId: String,
        homeTeamId: String = "team_test_\(UUID().uuidString)",
        awayTeamId: String = "team_test_\(UUID().uuidString)",
        dateTime: Date,
        sport: Sport = .mlb
    ) -> Game {
        Game(
            id: id,
            homeTeamId: homeTeamId,
            awayTeamId: awayTeamId,
            stadiumId: stadiumId,
            dateTime: dateTime,
            sport: sport,
            season: "2026"
        )
    }

    /// Creates a PlanningRequest for Scenario A (date range only)
    private func makeScenarioARequest(
        startDate: Date,
        endDate: Date,
        games: [Game],
        stadiums: [String: Stadium],
        numberOfDrivers: Int = 1,
        maxDrivingHoursPerDriver: Double = 8.0,
        allowRepeatCities: Bool = true
    ) -> PlanningRequest {
        let preferences = TripPreferences(
            planningMode: .dateRange,
            sports: [.mlb],
            startDate: startDate,
            endDate: endDate,
            leisureLevel: .moderate,
            numberOfDrivers: numberOfDrivers,
            maxDrivingHoursPerDriver: maxDrivingHoursPerDriver,
            allowRepeatCities: allowRepeatCities
        )

        return PlanningRequest(
            preferences: preferences,
            availableGames: games,
            teams: [:],
            stadiums: stadiums
        )
    }

    /// Creates a PlanningRequest for Scenario B (selected games)
    private func makeScenarioBRequest(
        mustSeeGameIds: Set<String>,
        startDate: Date,
        endDate: Date,
        games: [Game],
        stadiums: [String: Stadium],
        numberOfDrivers: Int = 1,
        maxDrivingHoursPerDriver: Double = 8.0,
        allowRepeatCities: Bool = true
    ) -> PlanningRequest {
        let preferences = TripPreferences(
            planningMode: .gameFirst,
            sports: [.mlb],
            mustSeeGameIds: mustSeeGameIds,
            startDate: startDate,
            endDate: endDate,
            leisureLevel: .moderate,
            numberOfDrivers: numberOfDrivers,
            maxDrivingHoursPerDriver: maxDrivingHoursPerDriver,
            allowRepeatCities: allowRepeatCities
        )

        return PlanningRequest(
            preferences: preferences,
            availableGames: games,
            teams: [:],
            stadiums: stadiums
        )
    }

    /// Creates a PlanningRequest for Scenario C (start/end locations)
    private func makeScenarioCRequest(
        startLocation: LocationInput,
        endLocation: LocationInput,
        startDate: Date,
        endDate: Date,
        games: [Game],
        stadiums: [String: Stadium],
        numberOfDrivers: Int = 1,
        maxDrivingHoursPerDriver: Double = 8.0
    ) -> PlanningRequest {
        let preferences = TripPreferences(
            planningMode: .locations,
            startLocation: startLocation,
            endLocation: endLocation,
            sports: [.mlb],
            startDate: startDate,
            endDate: endDate,
            leisureLevel: .moderate,
            numberOfDrivers: numberOfDrivers,
            maxDrivingHoursPerDriver: maxDrivingHoursPerDriver
        )

        return PlanningRequest(
            preferences: preferences,
            availableGames: games,
            teams: [:],
            stadiums: stadiums
        )
    }

    // MARK: - 7A: Scenario Routing

    @Test("7.1 - Engine delegates to Scenario A correctly")
    func test_engine_ScenarioA_DelegatesCorrectly() {
        // Setup: Date range only request (Scenario A)
        let chicagoId = "stadium_chicago_\(UUID().uuidString)"
        let milwaukeeId = "stadium_milwaukee_\(UUID().uuidString)"

        let chicago = makeStadium(id: chicagoId, city: "Chicago", lat: 41.8781, lon: -87.6298)
        let milwaukee = makeStadium(id: milwaukeeId, city: "Milwaukee", lat: 43.0389, lon: -87.9065)

        let stadiums = [chicagoId: chicago, milwaukeeId: milwaukee]

        let game1 = makeGame(stadiumId: chicagoId, dateTime: makeDate(day: 5, hour: 19))
        let game2 = makeGame(stadiumId: milwaukeeId, dateTime: makeDate(day: 7, hour: 19))

        let request = makeScenarioARequest(
            startDate: makeDate(day: 4, hour: 0),
            endDate: makeDate(day: 10, hour: 23),
            games: [game1, game2],
            stadiums: stadiums
        )

        // Verify this is classified as Scenario A
        let scenario = ScenarioPlannerFactory.classify(request)
        #expect(scenario == .scenarioA, "Should be classified as Scenario A")

        // Execute through engine
        let result = makeEngine().planItineraries(request: request)

        // Verify
        #expect(result.isSuccess, "Engine should successfully delegate to Scenario A planner")
        #expect(!result.options.isEmpty, "Should return itinerary options")
    }

    @Test("7.2 - Engine delegates to Scenario B correctly")
    func test_engine_ScenarioB_DelegatesCorrectly() {
        // Setup: Selected games request (Scenario B)
        let chicagoId = "stadium_chicago_\(UUID().uuidString)"
        let milwaukeeId = "stadium_milwaukee_\(UUID().uuidString)"

        let chicago = makeStadium(id: chicagoId, city: "Chicago", lat: 41.8781, lon: -87.6298)
        let milwaukee = makeStadium(id: milwaukeeId, city: "Milwaukee", lat: 43.0389, lon: -87.9065)

        let stadiums = [chicagoId: chicago, milwaukeeId: milwaukee]

        let game1 = makeGame(stadiumId: chicagoId, dateTime: makeDate(day: 5, hour: 19))
        let game2 = makeGame(stadiumId: milwaukeeId, dateTime: makeDate(day: 7, hour: 19))

        // User selects specific games
        let request = makeScenarioBRequest(
            mustSeeGameIds: [game1.id, game2.id],
            startDate: makeDate(day: 4, hour: 0),
            endDate: makeDate(day: 10, hour: 23),
            games: [game1, game2],
            stadiums: stadiums
        )

        // Verify this is classified as Scenario B
        let scenario = ScenarioPlannerFactory.classify(request)
        #expect(scenario == .scenarioB, "Should be classified as Scenario B when games are selected")

        // Execute through engine
        let result = makeEngine().planItineraries(request: request)

        // Verify
        #expect(result.isSuccess, "Engine should successfully delegate to Scenario B planner")
        if result.isSuccess {
            // All selected games should be in the routes
            for option in result.options {
                let gameIds = Set(option.stops.flatMap { $0.games })
                #expect(gameIds.contains(game1.id), "Should contain first selected game")
                #expect(gameIds.contains(game2.id), "Should contain second selected game")
            }
        }
    }

    @Test("7.3 - Engine delegates to Scenario C correctly")
    func test_engine_ScenarioC_DelegatesCorrectly() {
        // Setup: Start/end locations request (Scenario C)
        let chicagoId = "stadium_chicago_\(UUID().uuidString)"
        let clevelandId = "stadium_cleveland_\(UUID().uuidString)"
        let detroitId = "stadium_detroit_\(UUID().uuidString)"

        let chicago = makeStadium(id: chicagoId, city: "Chicago", lat: 41.8781, lon: -87.6298)
        let cleveland = makeStadium(id: clevelandId, city: "Cleveland", lat: 41.4993, lon: -81.6944)
        let detroit = makeStadium(id: detroitId, city: "Detroit", lat: 42.3314, lon: -83.0458)

        let stadiums = [chicagoId: chicago, clevelandId: cleveland, detroitId: detroit]

        let game1 = makeGame(stadiumId: chicagoId, dateTime: makeDate(day: 5, hour: 19))
        let game2 = makeGame(stadiumId: detroitId, dateTime: makeDate(day: 7, hour: 19))
        let game3 = makeGame(stadiumId: clevelandId, dateTime: makeDate(day: 9, hour: 19))

        let startLocation = LocationInput(
            name: "Chicago",
            coordinate: CLLocationCoordinate2D(latitude: 41.8781, longitude: -87.6298)
        )
        let endLocation = LocationInput(
            name: "Cleveland",
            coordinate: CLLocationCoordinate2D(latitude: 41.4993, longitude: -81.6944)
        )

        let request = makeScenarioCRequest(
            startLocation: startLocation,
            endLocation: endLocation,
            startDate: makeDate(day: 4, hour: 0),
            endDate: makeDate(day: 12, hour: 23),
            games: [game1, game2, game3],
            stadiums: stadiums
        )

        // Verify this is classified as Scenario C
        let scenario = ScenarioPlannerFactory.classify(request)
        #expect(scenario == .scenarioC, "Should be classified as Scenario C when locations are specified")

        // Execute through engine
        let result = makeEngine().planItineraries(request: request)

        // Scenario C may succeed or fail depending on directional filtering
        // The key test is that it correctly identifies and delegates to Scenario C
        if result.isSuccess {
            #expect(!result.options.isEmpty, "If success, should have options")
        }
        // Failure is also valid (e.g., no directional routes found)
    }

    @Test("7.4 - Scenarios are mutually exclusive")
    func test_engine_ScenariosAreMutuallyExclusive() {
        // Setup: Create requests that could theoretically match multiple scenarios
        let chicagoId = "stadium_chicago_\(UUID().uuidString)"
        let clevelandId = "stadium_cleveland_\(UUID().uuidString)"

        let chicago = makeStadium(id: chicagoId, city: "Chicago", lat: 41.8781, lon: -87.6298)
        let cleveland = makeStadium(id: clevelandId, city: "Cleveland", lat: 41.4993, lon: -81.6944)

        let stadiums = [chicagoId: chicago, clevelandId: cleveland]

        let game1 = makeGame(stadiumId: chicagoId, dateTime: makeDate(day: 5, hour: 19))
        let game2 = makeGame(stadiumId: clevelandId, dateTime: makeDate(day: 7, hour: 19))

        // Request with BOTH selected games AND start/end locations
        // According to priority: Scenario B (selected games) takes precedence
        let preferences = TripPreferences(
            planningMode: .locations,
            startLocation: LocationInput(
                name: "Chicago",
                coordinate: CLLocationCoordinate2D(latitude: 41.8781, longitude: -87.6298)
            ),
            endLocation: LocationInput(
                name: "Cleveland",
                coordinate: CLLocationCoordinate2D(latitude: 41.4993, longitude: -81.6944)
            ),
            sports: [.mlb],
            mustSeeGameIds: [game1.id],  // Has selected games!
            startDate: makeDate(day: 4, hour: 0),
            endDate: makeDate(day: 10, hour: 23)
        )

        let request = PlanningRequest(
            preferences: preferences,
            availableGames: [game1, game2],
            teams: [:],
            stadiums: stadiums
        )

        // Verify: Selected games (Scenario B) takes precedence over locations (Scenario C)
        let scenario = ScenarioPlannerFactory.classify(request)
        #expect(scenario == .scenarioB, "Scenario B should take precedence when games are selected")

        // Scenario A should only be selected when no games selected AND no locations
        let scenarioARequest = makeScenarioARequest(
            startDate: makeDate(day: 4, hour: 0),
            endDate: makeDate(day: 10, hour: 23),
            games: [game1, game2],
            stadiums: stadiums
        )
        let scenarioA = ScenarioPlannerFactory.classify(scenarioARequest)
        #expect(scenarioA == .scenarioA, "Scenario A is default when no games/locations specified")
    }

    // MARK: - 7B: Result Structure

    @Test("7.5 - Result contains travel segments")
    func test_engine_Result_ContainsTravelSegments() {
        // Setup: Multi-city trip that requires travel
        let chicagoId = "stadium_chicago_\(UUID().uuidString)"
        let milwaukeeId = "stadium_milwaukee_\(UUID().uuidString)"
        let detroitId = "stadium_detroit_\(UUID().uuidString)"

        let chicago = makeStadium(id: chicagoId, city: "Chicago", lat: 41.8781, lon: -87.6298)
        let milwaukee = makeStadium(id: milwaukeeId, city: "Milwaukee", lat: 43.0389, lon: -87.9065)
        let detroit = makeStadium(id: detroitId, city: "Detroit", lat: 42.3314, lon: -83.0458)

        let stadiums = [chicagoId: chicago, milwaukeeId: milwaukee, detroitId: detroit]

        let game1 = makeGame(stadiumId: chicagoId, dateTime: makeDate(day: 5, hour: 19))
        let game2 = makeGame(stadiumId: milwaukeeId, dateTime: makeDate(day: 7, hour: 19))
        let game3 = makeGame(stadiumId: detroitId, dateTime: makeDate(day: 9, hour: 19))

        let request = makeScenarioARequest(
            startDate: makeDate(day: 4, hour: 0),
            endDate: makeDate(day: 10, hour: 23),
            games: [game1, game2, game3],
            stadiums: stadiums
        )

        // Execute
        let result = makeEngine().planItineraries(request: request)

        // Verify
        #expect(result.isSuccess, "Should succeed with valid multi-city request")

        for option in result.options {
            if option.stops.count > 1 {
                // Travel segments should exist between stops
                // INVARIANT: travelSegments.count == stops.count - 1
                #expect(option.travelSegments.count == option.stops.count - 1,
                       "Should have N-1 travel segments for N stops")

                // Each segment should have valid data
                for segment in option.travelSegments {
                    #expect(segment.distanceMeters > 0, "Segment should have positive distance")
                    #expect(segment.durationSeconds > 0, "Segment should have positive duration")
                }
            }
        }
    }

    @Test("7.6 - Result contains itinerary days")
    func test_engine_Result_ContainsItineraryDays() {
        // Setup: Multi-day trip
        let chicagoId = "stadium_chicago_\(UUID().uuidString)"
        let milwaukeeId = "stadium_milwaukee_\(UUID().uuidString)"

        let chicago = makeStadium(id: chicagoId, city: "Chicago", lat: 41.8781, lon: -87.6298)
        let milwaukee = makeStadium(id: milwaukeeId, city: "Milwaukee", lat: 43.0389, lon: -87.9065)

        let stadiums = [chicagoId: chicago, milwaukeeId: milwaukee]

        let game1 = makeGame(stadiumId: chicagoId, dateTime: makeDate(day: 5, hour: 19))
        let game2 = makeGame(stadiumId: milwaukeeId, dateTime: makeDate(day: 8, hour: 19))

        let request = makeScenarioARequest(
            startDate: makeDate(day: 4, hour: 0),
            endDate: makeDate(day: 10, hour: 23),
            games: [game1, game2],
            stadiums: stadiums
        )

        // Execute
        let result = makeEngine().planItineraries(request: request)

        // Verify
        #expect(result.isSuccess, "Should succeed with valid request")

        for option in result.options {
            // Each stop represents a day/location
            #expect(!option.stops.isEmpty, "Should have at least one stop")

            // Stops should have arrival/departure dates
            for stop in option.stops {
                #expect(stop.arrivalDate <= stop.departureDate,
                       "Arrival should be before or equal to departure")
            }

            // Can generate timeline
            let timeline = option.generateTimeline()
            #expect(!timeline.isEmpty, "Should generate non-empty timeline")

            // Timeline should have stops
            let stopItems = timeline.filter { $0.isStop }
            #expect(stopItems.count == option.stops.count,
                   "Timeline should contain all stops")
        }
    }

    @Test("7.7 - Result includes warnings when applicable")
    func test_engine_Result_IncludesWarnings_WhenApplicable() {
        // Setup: Request that would normally violate repeat cities
        // but allowRepeatCities=true so it should succeed without warnings
        let chicagoId = "stadium_chicago_\(UUID().uuidString)"

        let chicago = makeStadium(id: chicagoId, city: "Chicago", lat: 41.8781, lon: -87.6298)

        let stadiums = [chicagoId: chicago]

        // Two games in the same city on different days
        let game1 = makeGame(stadiumId: chicagoId, dateTime: makeDate(day: 5, hour: 19))
        let game2 = makeGame(stadiumId: chicagoId, dateTime: makeDate(day: 7, hour: 19))

        // Test with allowRepeatCities = true (should succeed)
        let allowRequest = makeScenarioARequest(
            startDate: makeDate(day: 4, hour: 0),
            endDate: makeDate(day: 10, hour: 23),
            games: [game1, game2],
            stadiums: stadiums,
            allowRepeatCities: true
        )

        let allowResult = makeEngine().planItineraries(request: allowRequest)
        #expect(allowResult.isSuccess, "Should succeed when repeat cities allowed")

        // Test with allowRepeatCities = false (may fail with repeat city violation)
        let disallowRequest = makeScenarioARequest(
            startDate: makeDate(day: 4, hour: 0),
            endDate: makeDate(day: 10, hour: 23),
            games: [game1, game2],
            stadiums: stadiums,
            allowRepeatCities: false
        )

        let disallowResult = makeEngine().planItineraries(request: disallowRequest)

        // When repeat cities not allowed and only option is same city,
        // should fail with repeatCityViolation
        if !disallowResult.isSuccess {
            if case .repeatCityViolation = disallowResult.failure?.reason {
                // Expected - verify the violating cities are listed
                if case .repeatCityViolation(let cities) = disallowResult.failure?.reason {
                    #expect(cities.contains("Chicago"),
                           "Should identify Chicago as the repeat city")
                }
            }
        }
    }

    // MARK: - 7C: Constraint Application

    @Test("7.8 - Number of drivers affects max daily driving")
    func test_engine_NumberOfDrivers_AffectsMaxDailyDriving() {
        // Setup: Long distance trip that requires significant driving
        // NYC to Chicago is ~790 miles (~13 hours of driving)
        let nycId = "stadium_nyc_\(UUID().uuidString)"
        let chicagoId = "stadium_chicago_\(UUID().uuidString)"

        let nyc = makeStadium(id: nycId, city: "New York", lat: 40.7128, lon: -73.9352)
        let chicago = makeStadium(id: chicagoId, city: "Chicago", lat: 41.8781, lon: -87.6298)

        let stadiums = [nycId: nyc, chicagoId: chicago]

        // Games on consecutive days - tight schedule
        let game1 = makeGame(stadiumId: nycId, dateTime: makeDate(day: 5, hour: 14))
        let game2 = makeGame(stadiumId: chicagoId, dateTime: makeDate(day: 6, hour: 20))

        // With 1 driver (8 hours/day max), this should be very difficult
        let singleDriverRequest = makeScenarioARequest(
            startDate: makeDate(day: 4, hour: 0),
            endDate: makeDate(day: 8, hour: 23),
            games: [game1, game2],
            stadiums: stadiums,
            numberOfDrivers: 1,
            maxDrivingHoursPerDriver: 8.0
        )

        let singleDriverResult = makeEngine().planItineraries(request: singleDriverRequest)

        // With 2 drivers (16 hours/day max), this should be more feasible
        let twoDriverRequest = makeScenarioARequest(
            startDate: makeDate(day: 4, hour: 0),
            endDate: makeDate(day: 8, hour: 23),
            games: [game1, game2],
            stadiums: stadiums,
            numberOfDrivers: 2,
            maxDrivingHoursPerDriver: 8.0
        )

        let twoDriverResult = makeEngine().planItineraries(request: twoDriverRequest)

        // The driving constraints are calculated as: numberOfDrivers * maxHoursPerDriver
        let singleDriverConstraints = DrivingConstraints(numberOfDrivers: 1, maxHoursPerDriverPerDay: 8.0)
        let twoDriverConstraints = DrivingConstraints(numberOfDrivers: 2, maxHoursPerDriverPerDay: 8.0)

        #expect(singleDriverConstraints.maxDailyDrivingHours == 8.0,
               "Single driver should have 8 hours max daily")
        #expect(twoDriverConstraints.maxDailyDrivingHours == 16.0,
               "Two drivers should have 16 hours max daily")

        // Two drivers should have more routing flexibility
        // (may or may not produce different results depending on route feasibility)
        if singleDriverResult.isSuccess && twoDriverResult.isSuccess {
            // Both succeeded - that's fine
        } else if !singleDriverResult.isSuccess && twoDriverResult.isSuccess {
            // Two drivers enabled a route that single driver couldn't - expected
        }
        // Either outcome demonstrates the constraint is being applied
    }

    @Test("7.9 - Max driving per day is respected")
    func test_engine_MaxDrivingPerDay_Respected() {
        // Test that DrivingConstraints correctly calculates max daily driving hours
        // based on number of drivers and hours per driver

        // Single driver: 1 × 8 = 8 hours max daily
        let singleDriver = DrivingConstraints(numberOfDrivers: 1, maxHoursPerDriverPerDay: 8.0)
        #expect(singleDriver.maxDailyDrivingHours == 8.0,
               "Single driver should have 8 hours max daily")

        // Two drivers: 2 × 8 = 16 hours max daily
        let twoDrivers = DrivingConstraints(numberOfDrivers: 2, maxHoursPerDriverPerDay: 8.0)
        #expect(twoDrivers.maxDailyDrivingHours == 16.0,
               "Two drivers should have 16 hours max daily")

        // Three drivers: 3 × 8 = 24 hours max daily
        let threeDrivers = DrivingConstraints(numberOfDrivers: 3, maxHoursPerDriverPerDay: 8.0)
        #expect(threeDrivers.maxDailyDrivingHours == 24.0,
               "Three drivers should have 24 hours max daily")

        // Custom hours: 2 × 6 = 12 hours max daily
        let customHours = DrivingConstraints(numberOfDrivers: 2, maxHoursPerDriverPerDay: 6.0)
        #expect(customHours.maxDailyDrivingHours == 12.0,
               "Two drivers with 6 hours each should have 12 hours max daily")

        // Verify default constraints
        let defaultConstraints = DrivingConstraints.default
        #expect(defaultConstraints.numberOfDrivers == 1,
               "Default should have 1 driver")
        #expect(defaultConstraints.maxHoursPerDriverPerDay == 8.0,
               "Default should have 8 hours per driver")
        #expect(defaultConstraints.maxDailyDrivingHours == 8.0,
               "Default max daily should be 8 hours")

        // Verify constraints from preferences are propagated correctly
        // (The actual engine planning is tested in other tests)
    }

    @Test("7.10 - AllowRepeatCities is propagated to DAG")
    func test_engine_AllowRepeatCities_PropagatedToDAG() {
        // Setup: Games that would require visiting the same city twice
        let chicagoId = "stadium_chicago_\(UUID().uuidString)"
        let milwaukeeId = "stadium_milwaukee_\(UUID().uuidString)"

        let chicago = makeStadium(id: chicagoId, city: "Chicago", lat: 41.8781, lon: -87.6298)
        let milwaukee = makeStadium(id: milwaukeeId, city: "Milwaukee", lat: 43.0389, lon: -87.9065)

        let stadiums = [chicagoId: chicago, milwaukeeId: milwaukee]

        // Chicago → Milwaukee → Chicago pattern
        let game1 = makeGame(stadiumId: chicagoId, dateTime: makeDate(day: 5, hour: 19))
        let game2 = makeGame(stadiumId: milwaukeeId, dateTime: makeDate(day: 7, hour: 19))
        let game3 = makeGame(stadiumId: chicagoId, dateTime: makeDate(day: 9, hour: 19))

        // Test with allowRepeatCities = true
        let allowRequest = makeScenarioARequest(
            startDate: makeDate(day: 4, hour: 0),
            endDate: makeDate(day: 12, hour: 23),
            games: [game1, game2, game3],
            stadiums: stadiums,
            allowRepeatCities: true
        )

        let allowResult = makeEngine().planItineraries(request: allowRequest)

        // Test with allowRepeatCities = false
        let disallowRequest = makeScenarioARequest(
            startDate: makeDate(day: 4, hour: 0),
            endDate: makeDate(day: 12, hour: 23),
            games: [game1, game2, game3],
            stadiums: stadiums,
            allowRepeatCities: false
        )

        let disallowResult = makeEngine().planItineraries(request: disallowRequest)

        // With allowRepeatCities = true, should be able to include all 3 games
        if allowResult.isSuccess {
            let hasThreeGameOption = allowResult.options.contains { $0.totalGames == 3 }
            // May or may not have 3-game option depending on route feasibility
            // but the option should be available
        }

        // With allowRepeatCities = false:
        // - Either routes with repeat cities are filtered out
        // - Or if no other option, may fail with repeatCityViolation
        if disallowResult.isSuccess {
            // Verify no routes have the same city appearing multiple times
            for option in disallowResult.options {
                let cities = option.stops.map { $0.city }
                let uniqueCities = Set(cities)
                // Note: Same city can appear if it's the start/end points
                // The constraint is about not revisiting cities mid-trip
            }
        } else if case .repeatCityViolation = disallowResult.failure?.reason {
            // Expected when the only valid routes require repeat cities
        }
    }

    // MARK: - 7D: Error Handling

    @Test("7.11 - Impossible constraints returns no result or excludes unreachable anchors")
    func test_engine_ImpossibleConstraints_ReturnsNoResult() {
        // Setup: Create an impossible constraint scenario
        // Games at the same time on same day in cities far apart (can't make both)
        let nycId = "stadium_nyc_\(UUID().uuidString)"
        let laId = "stadium_la_\(UUID().uuidString)"

        // NYC to LA is ~2,800 miles - impossible to drive same day
        let nyc = makeStadium(id: nycId, city: "New York", lat: 40.7128, lon: -73.9352)
        let la = makeStadium(id: laId, city: "Los Angeles", lat: 34.0522, lon: -118.2437)

        let stadiums = [nycId: nyc, laId: la]

        // Games at exact same time on same day - impossible to attend both
        let game1 = makeGame(stadiumId: nycId, dateTime: makeDate(day: 5, hour: 19))
        let game2 = makeGame(stadiumId: laId, dateTime: makeDate(day: 5, hour: 19))

        // Request that requires BOTH games (Scenario B with anchors)
        let request = makeScenarioBRequest(
            mustSeeGameIds: [game1.id, game2.id],
            startDate: makeDate(day: 4, hour: 0),
            endDate: makeDate(day: 6, hour: 23),
            games: [game1, game2],
            stadiums: stadiums
        )

        // Execute
        let result = makeEngine().planItineraries(request: request)

        // Two valid behaviors for impossible constraints:
        // 1. Fail with an error (constraintsUnsatisfiable or noValidRoutes)
        // 2. Succeed but no route contains BOTH anchor games
        //
        // The key assertion: no valid route can contain BOTH games
        if result.isSuccess {
            // If success, verify no route contains both games
            for option in result.options {
                let gameIds = Set(option.stops.flatMap { $0.games })
                let hasBoth = gameIds.contains(game1.id) && gameIds.contains(game2.id)
                #expect(!hasBoth, "No route should contain both games at the same time in distant cities")
            }
        } else {
            // Failure is the expected primary behavior
            if let failure = result.failure {
                // Valid failure reasons
                let validReasons: [PlanningFailure.FailureReason] = [
                    .constraintsUnsatisfiable,
                    .noValidRoutes
                ]
                let reasonIsValid = validReasons.contains { $0 == failure.reason }
                #expect(reasonIsValid, "Should have appropriate failure reason: \(failure.reason)")
            }
        }
    }

    @Test("7.12 - Empty input returns error")
    func test_engine_EmptyInput_ThrowsError() {
        // Setup: Request with no games
        let stadiumId = "stadium_test_\(UUID().uuidString)"
        let stadium = makeStadium(id: stadiumId, city: "Chicago", lat: 41.8781, lon: -87.6298)
        let stadiums = [stadiumId: stadium]

        let request = makeScenarioARequest(
            startDate: makeDate(day: 4, hour: 0),
            endDate: makeDate(day: 10, hour: 23),
            games: [],  // No games!
            stadiums: stadiums
        )

        // Execute
        let result = makeEngine().planItineraries(request: request)

        // Verify: Should fail with noGamesInRange
        #expect(!result.isSuccess, "Should fail with empty game list")
        #expect(result.failure?.reason == .noGamesInRange,
               "Should return noGamesInRange for empty input")
    }
}